Mountaineer's Route · Sawtooth Wilderness, Idaho · 9,670 ft
SW Face · FA: Webster, Herbert, Hennek 1967 · ~860 ft
III · 5.9 · 7–8P
P15.8~180 ft
Start in the gully (5.5). Go 20–30 ft up gully then exit LEFT via 5.8 mantle (good divot on right edge, good feet below). Above: easy crack to pine tree B1. Alt: start on slabs left of gully.
⚡ RUNOUT: Pro at/below feet at the mantle. Commit carefully.
#0.5#0.75#1#2sm-md nutsalpine draws
B1: Pine tree (slings) + #0.75–#1 cam backup.
P25.8~180 ft
Big left-facing dihedral. DO NOT traverse left at first ledge (old bolts may be gone). Go 15 more feet up then find the obvious leftward ledge to the gorgeous hand-jam crack. 2-bolt belay below triple roofs (B2).
⚡ TRAP: Chalked false features at first ledge lure climbers left too early. Multiple parties made this error.
#0.5×2#0.75×2#1×2#2offset nutslong draws
B2: 2 modern bolts — best anchor on route. + optional cam backup.
P35.7–5.8~160 ft
From B3: slabby terrain trending slightly right toward the large blank diamond. Low angle but sparse pro. B4 is a good gear ledge directly below the diamond feature.
The long "slabby 5.8" section up the left edge of the large blank diamond — labeled exactly this in Steph's photo. Exposed and airy. Stop at B5 at the base of the crux finger crack. Do not over-run this belay.
⚡ STOP AT FINGER CRACK: Running 20–30 ft past B5 causes severe rope drag on the crux.
#0.3#0.4#0.5×2#0.75×2#1sm-md nuts
B5: Flared placements — #0.3–#0.5 ×2 + SMALL/OFFSET NUTS (critical per multiple sources). May need re-engineering.
P65.9 ★ CRUX~150 ft
Off B5: undercling traverse immediately into a lieback — get 2 pieces in before firing (mungy rock). The 5.9 crux — sweaty hands = real fall. Above: #3 Camalot at base of overhanging wide crack (hand-to-fist, 20 ft). Exit via left crack. Belay at comfortable stance.
☠ FATALITIES (1980s): Loose flake anchor pulled, killing 2. Test every flake.
☠ OFF-ROUTE: If holds run out left → wrong crack. Traverse RIGHT on thin hands.
#0.3×2#0.4×2#0.5#0.75#1#2#3 KEYsm nuts2 PIECES IN CRUX
B6: #0.75–#1 + #1–#2 + nut at comfortable stance.
P7Easy / 3rd–4th~100 ft
Broken rock, wide cracks, scrambling. Photo says "5.7 5.9 / lotta 3rd" — some parties hit a short 5.9 move in the wide crack before the angle eases. Summit via additional scrambling beyond.
⚠ LOOSE ROCK: Most rockfall hazard on route. Helmet mandatory.
#1#2#3slings
Full Rack
Item
Spec
Qty
Priority
Rope
60m single (70m better for rap)
1
Essential
#0.1–#0.2
Silver micro cams
1 ea
Nice-to-have
#0.3 Teal
0.37–0.64"
2
P6 crux
#0.4 Purple
0.48–0.83"
2
P3, P6, anchors
#0.5 Pink
0.61–1.05"
2
Every pitch
#0.75 Yellow
0.77–1.32"
2
Every pitch + anchors
#1 Red
0.97–1.69"
2
All pitches + anchors
#2 Blue
1.34–2.32"
2
Hand jams, wide
#3 Gray
1.76–3.08"
1
P6 wide crack KEY
#4 Purple
2.38–4.14"
1
P6/P7 comfort
Nuts
Full Stopper set
1 set
All pitches
Offset nuts
HB Offset / DMM Peanut
4–6
B5 anchor — critical
Alpine draws
60 cm extendable
10–12
Every pitch
Slings 120cm
Double-length
2
Back-clean P3
Lockers
Locking biners
5–6
Anchors
Helmet
Mandatory
1 ea
Non-negotiable
Headlamp
Fresh batteries
1 ea
Mandatory
Belay Anchor Details
Belay
Type
Key Pieces
B1
Tree+gear
Slings + #0.75–#1 backup
B2
2 BOLTS
2 lockers + optional cam
B3
2 BOLTS
2 lockers + optional cam
B4
Gear
#0.75–#1 ×2 + solid nut
B5
Gear
#0.3–#0.5 ×2 + small/offset nuts — flared!
B6
Gear
#0.75–#1 + #1–#2 + nut at comfortable stance
☠ Historical Fatalities
P5–P6 ZONE — MID-1980s: Two climbers died when anchor behind a loose flake pulled. TM Herbert (first ascentionist): blocks are "big and loose enough to force creative stemming." Test every flake. Multi-piece anchors only. Never trust a single flake.
⚡ Run-Out Sections
P1 — Mantle: Pro at/below feet at the 5.8 mantle move.
Standard — SE Descent Gully: From top-out, traverse RIGHT (east). First gully-like feature is the descent gully — don't go too far. Loose dirt over talus.
Rappel at Base: Bolted 30m rap anchor. 70m rope = straight to ground. 60m may be short — knot ends + downclimb last bit. 50m needs a higher station.
Alternate: From top-out go climber's LEFT, downclimb and traverse around the perch bulk to meet the approach trail.
True Summit: Technical finish is below the high point. Add ~30–45 min for summit scramble via SE slabs.
⏱ Timing: Summit to camp <1 hour. Last boat from Redfish ~7 PM — confirm current schedule. Most parties: 5–8 hours from camp.
Field Beta
📸Base photo is Steph Abegg's route overlay (stephabegg.com, July 4 2014). Her magenta line is already in the photo. Our color-coded segments + callouts are layered on top.
🎽Doubles #0.3–#3 is the real rack. SafeSexAndGoreTex 2023: "used doubles of every color on at least one pitch." #4 only placed to get it off the harness.
🔩Small nuts are critical — confirmed by multiple independent sources. B5 anchor requires small/offset nuts in flared placements.
📏60m works for 7 pitches but most pitches use the full rope. 70m recommended for the descent rap.
⏰Start 6–7 AM from camp. Approach only 20–30 min from Saddleback Lakes. Route: 5–8 hrs.
🗺Route is on the FAR LEFT of the face as seen from the lake. Traverse left from camp along the base.
🌲Campfires NEVER allowed at Saddleback Lakes. Hang food with thin cord. Wag bags sold at Redfish Visitor Center.
⛵Boat shuttle ~$24 RT (2025). Confirm pickup times. Missing last boat = 5-mile walk in the dark.
🧗FA: Webster, Herbert, Hennek — 1967. Herbert: "Loose blocks were just part of climbing."
Sources
Steph Abegg / stephabegg.com (2014) · Mountain Project · SafeSexAndGoreTex (2023) · MountainWerks (2025) · KUHL Born in the Mountains (2024) · SnowBrains / WanderHigh (2013) · Climbing.com (2009) · ChossClimbers (2004) · SummitPost rack TR · Sawtooth Mountain Guides · Idaho: A Climbing Guide — T. Lopez (2000)
Permits & Logistics
Permit: Sawtooth Wilderness — free, self-issue at the trailhead register. No quota.
Boat shuttle: Redfish Lake Lodge shuttle to the inlet, ~$24 RT (2025) — saves ~5 mi each way. Confirm pickup times; last boat ~7 PM.
Approach: Inlet → Redfish Creek trail → social trail departs at a creek crossing → ~4 mi to Saddleback Lakes basecamp. Route is 20–30 min above camp, far LEFT of the face.
Season: mid-July–September, snow-free. Start 6–7 AM; off technical terrain by noon.
Team: lock partners — who leads the 5.9 crux? Plan lead swaps.
Trip Checklist
Field topo synthesized from 12+ independent sources. Pitch lengths and belay locations approximate.